Penelope Moore, SAUNDERS & ASSOCIATES
VARIES
 A 
37 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY
House · Active for Rent
5 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 2596 SF
$999,000
 A 
1 Dering Woods Road, Shelter Island, NY
Vacant Land · Active for Sale
3.10 Acres
$1,495,000
 A 
81 North Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
4 Bed · 2.5 Bath · 2264 SF
$1,895,000
 A 
29 Brander Parkway, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
4 Bed · 3 Bath · 2196 SF
$1,999,000
 A 
9 Behringer Lane, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
3 Bed · 2.5 Bath · 2780 SF
$2,275,000
 A 
27 Country Club Drive, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 3170 SF
$2,375,000
 A 
40 Dinah Rock Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
3 Bed · 3 Bath · 1897 SF
$2,475,000
 A 
17 Crescent Way, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
3 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 2750 SF
$3,100,000
 A 
5 Seagull Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
5 Bed · 5 Bath · 3072 SF
$4,950,000
 A 
17 Nostrand Parkway, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
3 Bed · 1.5 Bath · 1715 SF
$5,445,000
 A 
6-6A South Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Active for Sale
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1622 SF
$19,975,000
 A 
34A North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY
House · Active for Sale
5 Bed · 5 Bath · 4490 SF
$775,000
 S 
34 Rocky Point Road, Shelter Island, NY
Vacant Land · Sold on 6/16/2023
1.34 Acres
$985,000
 S 
15 North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 4/21/2022
2 Bed · 2 Bath · 1457 SF
$1,003,950
 S 
18 North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 9/16/2022
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1281 SF
$1,100,000
 S 
4 Bowditch Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 6/23/2023
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1365 SF
$1,565,000
 S 
39 Brander Parkway, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 4/04/2022
3 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 2333 SF
$1,645,000
 S 
30 Baldwin Road, Shelter Island, NY
House · Sold on 6/30/2022
3 Bed · 3 Bath · 3304 SF
$1,985,000
 S 
9 Sunshine Road, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 1/31/2024
3 Bed · 3 Bath · 2374 SF
$2,100,000
 S 
2 Sheep Pasture Lane, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 7/14/2023
3 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 2546 SF
$2,500,000
 S 
40 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY
Vacant Land · Sold on 9/02/2022
5.80 Acres
$1,850,000
 S 
8A Simpson Avenue, Shelter Island, NY
Vacant Land · Sold on 9/02/2022
5.04 Acres
$2,600,000
 S 
34 Country Club Drive, Shelter Island, NY
House · Sold on 11/18/2022
4 Bed · 5.5 Bath · 4000 SF
$3,250,000
 S 
14 Montclair Avenue, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 7/01/2022
4 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 2799 SF
$3,225,000
 S 
58 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island, NY
Residential · Sold on 6/16/2023
5 Bed · 4.5 Bath · 6625 SF